The Impact of Living in Rural and Urban Areas: Vitamin D and Medical Costs in Veterans

Beth A. Bailey PhD1, Todd Manning BA2, Alan N. Peiris MD, PhD 2,3
1 Department of Family Medicine, East Tennessee State University, Johnson City, Tennessee
2 Mountain Home Veterans Administration Medical Center, Mountain Home, Tennessee
3 Department of Internal Medicine, East Tennessee State University, Johnson City, Tennessee
© 2012 National Rural Health Association
The Journal of Rural Health, Article first published online: 4 APR 2012, DOI: 10.1111/j.1748-0361.2012.00407.x

Purpose: Living in a rural region is associated with significant health disparities and increased medical costs. Vitamin D deficiency, which is increasingly common, is also associated with many adverse health outcomes. The purpose of this study was to determine whether rural-urban residence status of veterans was related to vitamin D levels, and to determine if this factor also influenced medical costs/service utilization. Additionally explored was whether vitamin D differences accounted for part of the association between area of residence and medical costs/service utilization.

Methods: Medical records of 9,396 veterans from 6 Veterans Administration Medical Centers were reviewed for variables of interest including county of residence, vitamin D level, medical costs and service utilization, and background variables. Rurality status was classified as large metropolitan, urban, and rural.

Findings: The 3 rurality status groups differed significantly in vitamin D levels, with the highest levels observed for urban residents, followed by rural residents, and the lowest for large metro residents. Compared with urban residents, large metro residents were 49% more likely, while rural residents were 20% more likely, to be vitamin D deficient. Both rural and large metro residents had higher medical costs, and they were significantly more likely to be hospitalized. Vitamin D levels explained a statistically significant amount of the relationship between rurality status and medical costs/service utilization.

Conclusions: Vitamin D deficiency may be an additional health disparity experienced by both rural and inner-city veterans, and patients residing in these locations should be considered at increased risk for deficiency and routinely tested.
- - - - - - -

From Medscape

	ng/ml	Costs for outpatient care	Cost for inpatient care
Urban	29.5	$5455	$20,294
Rural	28.0	$6268	$23,275
Metro	27.5	$7493	$25,057

See also VitaminDWiki

• Black veterans have worse health and low vitamin D, yet are not tested as much – June 2011
  Authors = Peiris AN, Bailey BA, Peiris P, Copeland RJ, Manning T.
• Vitamin D might reduce military costs for UC and CD – June 2011
  Authors = Atia, Antwan; Murthy, Ravindra; Bailey, Beth A; Manning, Todd; Garrett, Linda L; Youssef, Dima; Peiris, Alan N
• VA found less testing for vitamin D resulted in increased health costs – Jan 2012
  Authors = Bailey, Beth Manning, Todd; Peiris, Alan N alan.peiris at va.gov
• Blacks living in urban area vs rural have less vitamin D if older than 50 – Oct 2011
  Candidate reasons for decrease of vitamin D in urban area include:
     Air pollution/haze reduces the UVB needed to make vitamin D
     Not go outdoors as much in urban area (feel less safe, availability of air conditioning, lack of garden)
• All items noontime sun and Vitamin D All items in category Predict Vitamin D] 331 items
• Urban residents had 2X less vitamin D – 2008
• 4X more suburban UV than urban UV – Nov 2010
• An overview analysis of the time people spend outdoors – Dec 2010
• Air pollution reduces UV and thus vitamin D - Aug 2010
• Another urban area in a sunny climate is vitamin D deficiency – Bangkok Nov 2011
• 27 reasons why vitamin D deficiency has become epidemic - and counting
• All items in category Predict Vitamin D 82 items