10X less frequent in sunny climates: MS, T1D, Hip Fracture, IBD, etc
Claude Opus 5.5 AI - Nov 2026
Five conditions show roughly a 10-fold gap or more in the published data: multiple sclerosis, childhood type 1 diabetes, hip fracture, colorectal cancer and probably IBD. Autism is reported as nearly unknown, but nobody has measured it. Alzheimer's and psoriasis are lower in Africa, but only by 2–3X. Rickets goes the other way: it's common in parts of sunny Africa.
Meets the ~10X bar (ratios are my arithmetic from the cited figures)
| Disease | Sub-Saharan Africa | High-latitude comparison | Approx. ratio | Main confounder | Refs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Multiple sclerosis | 2.1 per 100,000 (prevalence) | 108 Europe; 140 N. America; ~219 Finland/Sweden | ~50–100X | Few neurologists and MRIs | Atlas of MS 2013 Med Res Arch 2024 |
| Type 1 diabetes, children | 0.9–1.5 per 100,000/yr (Tanzania); <2 (E & W Africa, ages 0–19) | 52 Finland 2021, ~64 projected 2025 (ages 0–14); 39 N. Europe (ages 0–19) | ~20–70X | Many children die undiagnosed; HLA differences | Tanzania 2023 Scoping review 2022 IDF 2021 |
| Hip fracture | Cameroon, age-adjusted: 52 women / 44 men per 100,000 (2002); 86 / 73 (2006–09) | Norway 920 women / 399 men; US 957 women | ~10–18X women; ~5–9X men | Few people live past 65; higher bone density in Black Africans | Cheng 2010 Africa OP review 2020 |
| Colorectal cancer | Mozambique 3.6 per 100,000 (men); W. Africa 3.6 | Hungary 62 (men); Europe and Australia/NZ regions 40.6 (men) | ~10–17X | Low-fiber diet in the West; thin cancer registries in Africa | GLOBOCAN 2020 BMJ Open 2022 |
| IBD (Crohn's, UC) | Rare in most regions; no incidence data outside South Africa | Rose sharply in high-income countries | Probably >10X; not measured | Mistaken for TB or infection; parasitic worms | Front Med 2022 Lancet GH 2022 |
| Autism | Described as almost unknown in Somalia; no surveys | Somali children ~4X non-Somali in Stockholm; 1 in 32 in Minneapolis | Unknown | Not recognized; stigma | Spectrum 2008 Star Tribune via Newser |
Lower, but well short of 10X
| Disease | Africa | Comparison | Approx. ratio | Refs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alzheimer's | 1.41% prevalence, Yoruba in Ibadan | 3.69%, African Americans in Indianapolis; new cases 2X higher | ~2–2.5X | Hendrie 1995 Ogunniyi 2011 |
| Psoriasis | 1.7%; lowest in West Africa | 4.6% Europe | ~2.7X | Acta Derm Venereol J Autoimmun 2010 |
Rickets is not rare
- Rickets is common in parts of Nigeria. Up to 40% of children in one Gbagyi community have it (FAO/Hartmann 2012). Most of it comes from calcium intakes of only ~200 mg/day (Thacher 2000).
- Vitamin D still plays a part: children with rickets had a median 25(OH)D of 32 nmol/L, against 50 nmol/L in controls (Thacher 2000).
Caveats for using these figures
- A sunny country doesn't guarantee high vitamin D. Traditional Maasai and Hadzabe living 2–4° from the equator average 115 nmol/L (46 ng/mL) (Luxwolda 2012). The Nigerian control children averaged only 50 nmol/L.
- Every 10X row has a confounder big enough to explain much of the gap by itself. These include missed diagnoses (type 1 diabetes, IBD, MS), short lifespans (only ~1% of Cameroonians live past 65, per Zebaze 2003), genetics, worms and diet. The gaps are real in the data, but they can't all be credited to vitamin D.
- Migration studies are the strongest evidence that environment matters more than genes. North Africans who got MS after moving to France had an estimated prevalence of 76.8 per 100,000. For those who got it before leaving, the figure was 16.6 (Kurtzke 1998). That's North Africa rather than middle Africa, but the principle is the same as with autism in Somali families abroad.
Prostate cancer is a counter-example I didn't look up: rates are reported to be high in West African men.
Sources:
- Atlas of MS 2013 (Reuters)
- MS in sub-Saharan Africa, Med Res Arch 2024
- T1D in Tanzania, Front Endocrinol 2023
- T1D incidence scoping review, PLOS Glob Public Health 2022
- IDF 2021 top T1D countries
- Hip fracture rates worldwide, Cheng 2010
- Osteoporosis in Africa review 2020
- Hip fractures in Cameroon, Zebaze 2003
- GLOBOCAN 2020 colorectal summary
- Colorectal cancer in Africa, BMJ Open 2022
- IBD and helminths in SSA, Front Med 2022
- IBD in SSA, Lancet Gastroenterol Hepatol 2022
- Somali autism cluster, Spectrum 2008
- Minneapolis Somali autism, Newser 2013
- Alzheimer's in Ibadan vs Indianapolis, Hendrie 1995
- Alzheimer's incidence, Yoruba vs African Americans
- Psoriasis global prevalence, Acta Derm Venereol
- Psoriasis geoepidemiology, J Autoimmun 2010
- Rickets in Nigerian children, Thacher 2000
- Gbagyi rickets and calcium, FAO 2012
- Maasai and Hadzabe vitamin D, Luxwolda 2012
- MS in North African migrants to France, Kurtzke 1998
Related in VitaminDWiki
- Overview Autism and vitamin D
- Hip fractures and low Vitamin D - many studies
- Hip fractures greatly reduced by sunshine, vitamin D, and vitamin K – meta-analysis
- T1 Diabetes 3X lower risk if high vitamin D (over 40 ng) – Meta-analysis
- Type 1 Diabetes might be prevented by vitamin D - Dec 2025
- Overview Cancer-Colon and vitamin D
- Colorectal cancer 14 percent less likely if 10 ng more Vitamin D – 22nd meta-analysis
- Colon cancer both prevented and treated by Vitamin D – meta-analysis
- IBD treated by Vitamin D, provided enough or a gut-friendly form is used
- IBD in children might be associated with low sun exposure
- Overview MS and vitamin D
- Multiple Sclerosis 5.1 X more likely if poor sun and poor HLA-DRB1×15:01 - meta-analysis
- Multiple Sclerosis risk is increased 50% if low Vitamin D - 19 study meta-analysis
- Tanning bed twice a month slightly increased vitamin D levels during the winter – RCT
- Tanning: Worshipped for millenniums, demonized by Dermatologists for 40 years, is coming back
- Vitamin D from phototherapy lamps, tanning beds, and the sun
- Multiple Sclerosis much less likely for children who are thin and tanned
- Summary of Vitamin D Cost-Effectiveness in VitaminDWiki
- 21 reasons why doctors are reluctant to accept Vitamin D
- Overview -Proof that Vitamin D Works
Top 10
- The Top 10 Medical Expenses Can All Be Lowered by One Cheap Vitamin
- All of the top 10 happiest countries have sufficient Vitamin D levels (>20 ng)
- Top 10 chronic health problems of seniors are all related to low vitamin D
- All of the top 10 Chronic health problems are fought by Vitamin D
- Why people start taking Vitamin D (top 10 reasons)
- The top 10 medical expenses can all be decreased by vitamin D
- Vitamin D reduces the risk of 8 of the top 10 causes of death - Dr. Grant
- Top 10 chronic health problems of children, women, pregnancies, seniors, and darker skins are fought by Vitamin D
- Top 10 causes of death - low vitamin D is associated with every cause