Ethnic differences in vitamin D status, bone and body composition in South Asian indian and Caucasian men
Metabolism Open Volume 23 , Sept 2024, 100302 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.metop.2024.100302
Background
High prevalence of metabolic abnormalities and poor bone health in ethnic minorties may stem from differences in body composition and alterations in endocrine milieu. South Asian Indians (SAIs) are at greater risk for metabolic syndrome (MetS) and poor bone health than Caucasians. Often these differences are reported later in life and/or in a resident immigrant population compared to a Caucasian population. In this study, we determined whether vitamin D status, bone, body composition differed in young SAIs and Caucasians. Notably we compared differences amongst recent SAI immigrants and Caucasians.
Methods
We examined differences in bone density, body composition, serum 25-hydroxy vitamin D (s25(OH)D), parathyroid hormone (sPTH), vitamin D binding protein (sDBP), osteocalcin (sOC), and dietary intakes in young healthy SAI and Caucasian men.
Results
Sixty men (N = 30 SAIs and N = 30 Caucasians) with a mean age of 27.8 ± 7.4 years completed the study. Compared to the Caucasians, SAIs had statistically significantly lower s25(OH)D and higher sPTH (p < 0.05). We also found that s25(OH)D was negatively associated with sPTH only among the SAIs (r = - 0.389, p = 0.037). Also, lean mass% (LM%) and fat-free mass% (FFM%) were lower in SAIs (p < 0.05) compared to caucasians. s25(OH)D correlated with nearly all body composition parameters, while sPTH correlated negatively with LM% and FFM%, and positively with FM% (all p < 0.05) in the Caucasian group. Bone mineral density at most sites were also significantly lower (p < 0.05) in the SAI's compared to caucasians.
Conclusion
Young SAIs have a poor vitamin D status and less favorable bone and body composition parameters compared to Caucasians. These findings highlight the possible complex interplay between skeletal and metabolic health in different ethnicities which may be evident early on in life. Interventions to improve bone and metabolic health should therefore target younger ethnic minorities.
 Download the PDF from VitaminDWiki
65+ VitaminDWiki pages have INDIA or INDIAN in the title
The list is automatically updated
Items found: 69
Title |
|
Modified |
More brands of Calcitriol plus Calcium than Cholecalciferol (Vit D) in India, both have huge price ranges – Nov 2024 |
|
14 Nov, 2024 |
More brands of Calcitriol plus Calcium than Cholecalciferol (Vit D) in India, both have huge price ranges – Nov 2024 |
|
14 Nov, 2024 |
Psoriasis and Eczema Respond Well to Vitamin D Treatment (India) - Renu Oct 2023 |
|
27 Oct, 2024 |
India and vitamin D - many studies |
|
27 Oct, 2024 |
New immigrant South Asian Indian men have worse Vitamin D and bones than Caucasians (US) – Sept 2024 |
|
21 Aug, 2024 |
Increased vitamin D might decrease air pollution health problems (Pregnant women in India in this case) – June 2024 |
|
05 Jul, 2024 |
Rheumatoid Arthritis score extrapolates to zero at 51 ng of Vitamin D (India) – June 2024 |
|
05 Jul, 2024 |
Hay fever and autism 2X more likely if poor Vitamin D Receptor (children in India) - Jan 2024 |
|
15 Mar, 2024 |
4.4 X more likely to have a preterm birth if low vitamin D while pregnant (India) - May 2022 |
|
01 Nov, 2023 |
Consensus: 60,000 IU of Vitamin D weekly for 2-6 months can fight COVID, etc, – India April 2022 |
|
13 Oct, 2023 |
Native American Indians mostly died of skin cancer (nope) |
|
05 Feb, 2023 |
Table salt was fortified with Vitamin A, Iodine, etc in Indian Trial –Nov 2022 |
|
21 Nov, 2022 |
Increase in non-COVID deaths (ages 18-64) in Indiana, India, etc. - Jan 5, 2022 |
|
06 Jan, 2022 |
More people with Chronic Kidney Disease are now getting Vitamin D prescriptions (India) – Sept 2021 |
|
05 Sep, 2021 |
India raises RDAs - Vitamin D will be a measely 600 IU - July 2021 |
|
31 Jul, 2021 |
Very low Vitamin D in Indian pregnancies– 1 in 3 women not even have 20 ng – meta-analysis June 2021 |
|
30 Jun, 2021 |
COVID-21 (COVID-19 with mutations) causing increased pregnancy problems in Brazil and India – May 2021 |
|
27 May, 2021 |
COVID-19 has hit populist-lead countries hard (India, Brazil, US, UK, Mexico) – May 2021 |
|
09 May, 2021 |
COVID-19 protocol proposed in India includes Vitamin D - Nov 12, 2020 |
|
05 Dec, 2020 |
60,000 IU dose of VItamin D (weekly, monthly) is popular in India |
|
17 Nov, 2020 |
People from the Indian continent living in the UK continue to have extremely low levels of Vitamin D – July 2020 |
|
23 Jul, 2020 |
Vitamin-D: An Immune Shield Against COVID-19 – India May 21, 2020 |
|
22 May, 2020 |
Vitamin D levels from lowest to highest: Middle East, China. India, S EU. N EU – Dec 2019 |
|
14 Mar, 2020 |
Children in India – 1 in 7 extremely low Vitamin D, 1 in 10 prediabetic – Sept 2019 |
|
10 Oct, 2019 |
Low Vitamin D and Calcium in India – Aug 2019 |
|
09 Aug, 2019 |
Children need 2000 IU of Vitamin D (India) - RCT May 2019 |
|
19 May, 2019 |
Vitamin D level of outdoor workers in India was only 18 ng– May 2019 |
|
16 May, 2019 |
All preteen aged girls in India taking 2,000 IU of vitamin D got levels above 20 ng – RCT Nov 2018 |
|
08 Mar, 2019 |
India wants to cure Vitamin D Deficiency, unfortunately by fortifying with D2 not D3 – Jan 2019 |
|
16 Jan, 2019 |
2,000 IU of Vitamin D raised all girls to above 20 ng (India) – RCT Nov 2018 |
|
28 Dec, 2018 |
International Conference of Vitamin D Fortification of Food (India) – Sept 2018 |
|
02 Aug, 2018 |
Osteopenia in 40 percent of Indian women – May 2018 |
|
06 May, 2018 |
Each hour of outdoor work in India increased vitamin D levels by 2 nanograms – March 2017 |
|
18 May, 2017 |
Vitamin D fortification of edible oils in India starting in 2017 |
|
26 Mar, 2017 |
Preterm labor 20 times more likely if low vitamin D, etc. (India) – Feb 2017 |
|
08 Mar, 2017 |
Why India's vitamin D deficiency is grim - 40 pages Feb 2014 |
|
07 Mar, 2017 |
Type II Diabetes in children in India increased 4 X in 20 years – Nov 2016 |
|
22 Dec, 2016 |
Osteoporosis of Indian men in their 60’s (perhaps low vitamin D, K, and Mg) – Nov 2016 |
|
05 Dec, 2016 |
Diabetes (Type II) in youths in India now 4 times more likely than 20 years ago (Vit D not mentioned) – Nov 2016 |
|
22 Nov, 2016 |
Increasing number of people admitted to a hospital in India have very high vitamin D – Oct 2016 |
|
07 Oct, 2016 |
1 in 6 critically ill in India have high levels of vitamin D (100 ng) – March 2015 |
|
07 Oct, 2016 |
Vitamin D publications increasing around the world – emphasis on India – Oct 2016 |
|
10 Sep, 2016 |
Farmers in India have 2.5 times higher vitamin D than office workers – 2016 |
|
20 Aug, 2016 |
Caesarean emergency risk 2 X higher for Indian women (in sunny Singapore) – Nov 2015 |
|
26 Jul, 2016 |
Vitamin D deficiency a big problem in Pakistan, similar to India – July 2016 |
|
10 Jul, 2016 |
Universal pregnancy vitamin D supplementation for a hospital in India – study stopped after 1 month – April 2016 |
|
07 Apr, 2016 |
Caesarean emergency risk 2 X higher for Indian women with low Vitamin D – Nov 2015 |
|
21 Nov, 2015 |
Improved births with 2,000 IU vitamin D during pregnancy in India - RCT Feb 2015 |
|
12 Nov, 2015 |
Diabetic glycation control is inversely related to Vitamin D in India – Feb 2015 |
|
22 Apr, 2015 |
Vitamin D fortification of foods, cosmetics, by mfg and at home (India) - Sept 2014 |
|
20 Mar, 2015 |
80 percent of young adults had low vitamin D tests in Mumbai India - 2011 |
|
03 Dec, 2014 |
Vitamin D sachets in India – fewer than a third had the stated amount – Nov 2013 |
|
31 Aug, 2014 |
Children in India – vitamin D guidelines similar to IoM – July 2013 |
|
19 Mar, 2014 |
Rickets in 30 percent of infants in India who had low vitamin D – March 2011 |
|
22 Feb, 2014 |
20 percent of Critically ill in India had undetectable vitamin D, and 62 percent died – Jan 2013 |
|
22 Feb, 2014 |
Mothers and infants in India have very low levels of vitamin D – April 2012 |
|
12 Nov, 2013 |
90 percent of Indian mothers and infants had less than 20 ng of vitamin D – May 2011 |
|
12 Nov, 2013 |
Girls in India much faster when given Vitamin D, Ca, Zn, multi. – RCT Oct 2013 |
|
01 Nov, 2013 |
Girls in India grew much faster when given Vitamin D, Ca, Zn, multi. – RCT Oct 2013 |
|
24 Oct, 2013 |
Breast cancer increasing in India (perhaps due to lowering vitamin D) – Oct 2013 |
|
20 Oct, 2013 |
Virtually every gynaecologist in India is vitamin D deficient – Feb 2013 |
|
04 Feb, 2013 |
76 percent of young adults in western India had less than 20 ng of vitamin D – Aug 2011 |
|
04 Feb, 2013 |
Almost all newborns in India have less than 20 ng of vitamin D – Nov 2012 |
|
10 Dec, 2012 |
Hip fractures in India - editorial with recommendation - Sept 2010 |
|
06 Jul, 2012 |
Majority of infant seizures in India due to lack of vitamin D - July 2010 |
|
25 Jun, 2012 |
Seniors in North Indian: half have sore bones, 98 pcnt have less than 30 ng vitamin D – Nov 2011 |
|
24 May, 2012 |
Obesity in American-Indians and African-American teens |
|
17 Aug, 2010 |
Low BMD among teaching doctors in India - July 2010 |
|
09 Jul, 2010 |
A plea for vitamin D food fortification in India - May 2010 |
|
05 May, 2010 |
FACT - - People with dark skins have more health problems and higher mortality rate than those with light skins
FACT - - People with dark skins have low levels of vitamin D
FACT - - People with light skins who have low vitamin D have health problems
OBSERVATION - - The health problems of whites with low level of vitamin D are similar to those with dark skins
CONCLUSION - - People with dark skins have more health problems due to low levels of vitamin D
African American Health Disparities are associated with low Vitamin D - Grant Feb 2021
Low Vitamin D increases health problems - independent of skin color
Dark Skin studies: Pregnancy (29 |
studies), Genetics (13 |
studies), Vitamin D Binding Protein (8 |
studies), Vitamin D Receptor (7 |
studies), Diabetes (24 |
studies), Cardiovascular (18 |
studies), Mortality (12 |
studies), Intervention (16 |
studies) Click here to see the studies
This page is in the following categories (# of items in each category)
See any problem with this page? Report it (WORKS NOV 2021)
“One pill every two weeks fights diabetes, cancers, heart failure, and 21 other diseases.”
Click for details
|