Women with autoimmune disease are diagnosed later and more often told it is mental health – survey of 6,600

Sex and disease differences in patients’ diagnostic experiences in autoimmune diseases: an international cross-sectional study

eClinicalMedicine (Elsevier), Oct 2026, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eclinm.2026.104259

Melanie Sloan, Sydnae Taylor, Benjamin Cox, Kaira Kuhu Naidu, Rakesh Modi, Wendy Diment, Shaista Tayabali, Martha Piper, James Brimicombe, Arvind Kaul, David D’Cruz

Summary by Claude Opus 5.5 - November 2026

Women with autoimmune disease reported longer waits for diagnosis, more clinician visits, and more often having their symptoms blamed on mental health or "psychosomatic" causes than men with the same diseases.

This was a peer-reviewed cross-sectional online survey of 6,607 adults with a clinician-confirmed autoimmune or inflammatory rheumatic disease (self-reported), run Dec 2024 – Mar 2025: 91% women, 88% White, 70% in the UK. Autoimmune thyroid disease, lupus, Sjögren's and rheumatoid arthritis were the most common.

Women vs men:

  • Diagnosed within 1 year of first symptoms: 40% vs 50%
  • Waited 4 years or more: 32% vs 26%
  • 11+ clinician visits before diagnosis: 26% vs 18%
  • Symptoms attributed to a mental-health condition: 43% vs 33%
  • Symptoms called psychosomatic: 34% vs 22%
  • Misdiagnosed as another physical disease: 44% vs 48% (not significant)

Adjusted for age, disease, continent and household finances, women still had 1.5X the odds of a reported psychiatric misdiagnosis and 1.7X the odds of a psychosomatic one. Type 1 diabetes, RA and polymyalgia rheumatica had the fewest such misdiagnoses (<25%); autoimmune encephalitis and undifferentiated connective tissue disease the most (>50%). The authors urge clinicians to consider autoimmune disease early when symptoms are multi-system or "medically unexplained."

Vitamin D was not studied. The paper is here because autoimmune disease is a major VitaminDWiki topic that mostly affects women, and the VITAL RCT found 22% fewer confirmed new autoimmune diseases with 2,000 IU/day of vitamin D over about 5 years.

What this does NOT show

  • That clinicians were wrong – "misdiagnoses" are patient-perceived and unverified; some were likely early working diagnoses
  • Typical rates – online volunteers recruited via charities; people with bad experiences may be over-represented, and recall of years-old events is imperfect
  • Firm results for men – only 583 took part; several diseases had fewer than 10 men
  • Why the gap exists – bias, biology, and women's more frequent prior anxiety and fibromyalgia diagnoses cannot be separated
  • A big delay gap – the sex difference in time to diagnosis was statistically significant but small
  • Anything about vitamin D

The authors call the work "exploratory in nature and our findings should be interpreted cautiously."

Sources:


Related in VitaminDWiki

Disease in this survey Told "mental health": women vs men VitaminDWiki
Autoimmune thyroid (most common) ≈51% vs ≈39% Thyroid tag
Lupus (SLE) ≈47% vs ≈23% (largest gap) Lupus tag
Autoimmune skin disease ≈48% vs ≈44% Psoriasis tag
Inflammatory bowel disease ≈29% vs ≈35% (men higher) IBD tag
Rheumatoid arthritis ≈25% vs ≈20% (among lowest) Rheumatoid Arthritis tag
Type 1 diabetes Under 25% overall; too few men to compare Diabetes T1 tag
Multiple sclerosis Too few men to compare Multiple Sclerosis tag

Note: ≈ values were read by eye from Figure 2B of the paper; numbers of men per disease are small.

Click on a tag to see studies: Autoimmune (230) Women (410)