Shattered bones had far lower vitamin D than simple breaks (19 vs 31 ng)
Lower serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D levels are associated with greater fracture complexity in adult orthopaedic trauma patients: an OTA/AO classification-based cross-sectional study
OTA International (Wolters Kluwer), Nov 16, 2026, https://doi.org/10.1097/OI9.0000000000000533
Alejandro Xavier Barros Castro, Edgar Barros Prieto, Carlos Ballesteros Ponce, Carlos Eduardo Noboa Freile, Carlos Peñaherrera, Francisco Endara
Summary by Claude Opus 5.5 - November, 2026
Bottom line: Adults whose bones broke into many pieces arrived at the hospital with much lower vitamin D than adults with simple breaks, even after accounting for how violent the injury was.
Cross-sectional study of 126 adult fracture patients at 2 private hospitals in Quito, Ecuador (2023–2025). Vitamin D was measured at the first fracture evaluation, before surgery or any supplementation. Fractures were graded with the standard OTA/AO system.
| OTA/AO fracture type | Patients | Mean 25(OH)D | Deficient (<20 ng) |
|---|---|---|---|
| A – simple | 47 | 30.9 ng | 11% |
| B – wedge | 42 | 26.4 ng | 19% |
| C – multi-fragment | 37 | 18.7 ng | 70% |
After adjusting for age, sex, BMI category, injury energy, osteoporosis history and chronic steroid use, each 1 ng/mL higher vitamin D was linked to 14% lower odds of a more complex fracture (OR 0.86, 95% CI 0.81–0.91). Put another way, a person 10 ng lower had about 4.5X the odds of a more complex fracture. A high-energy injury (car crash, fall from over 1 m) raised the odds 3.8X. No vitamin D was given; these are levels at the time of the fracture.
What this does NOT show
- That low vitamin D caused the complex fractures, or that supplements would prevent them — the authors present it "not as evidence of a causal protective effect."
- That low vitamin D came first. Injury and inflammation can lower measured 25(OH)D — it fell about 40% within 2 days of knee-replacement surgery Reid 2011 AJCN. Time from injury to blood draw was not reported.
- That it applies to all fracture patients: only 136 of 400 (34%) were tested, at the doctors' discretion.
- That vitamin D, rather than overall nutrition, is the key factor. PTH, albumin and bone density were not measured, and normal-weight patients averaged 34 ng versus 18–23 ng in every other weight group.
- Anything about healing or complications, which were not tracked.
A large effect from one small study with some unusual features (30% on chronic steroids) is likely to shrink in larger studies.
Sources: