Argumentation assistance in discussions with doctors (translated from German)
MARTIN STEHLE · WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 16, 2016 Facebook
The usual experience of MS patients who want to get their doctor and neurologist for the Coimbra protocol is disappointing. Instead of openness and curiosity for a new, proven approach for years, neurologists show rejection.
In order to facilitate discussion with them, this document lists the common arguments that neurologists have made, as well as the best answers.
The option for a doctor to decide against therapy must be considered. Physicians have freedom of therapy, ie they can and may choose which therapy to use. Should a doctor decide against the Coimbra Protocol, it is his right. In this case you look for a new doctor.
Arguments and how to use them
Table of contents
- "Improvement in MS? Then the diagnosis was wrong."
- "Vitamin D is just a hype."
- "The results of the solar study are not significant (meaning not meaningful)."
- "The results of the solar study are sobering. Improvements were not detected. "
- "You should think about a basic therapy / you are a candidate for escalation therapy."
- "With such high doses of vitamin D, there is a risk of kidney failure."
- "With such high doses of vitamin D, kidney stones can form. Such doses can be deadly. "
- "This 'vitamin D resistance' is initially only a hypothesis without evidence."
- Previously in VitaminDWiki
- Added to VitaminDWiki after this page was originally written
- "Oh man, I thought you such a great Dignostiker! I think, then I need a new neurologist, who checks me all over again!"
- "Did you read the study that showed that vitamin D has remyelinating effects?" Mentioned in German here: https://www.dmsg.de/multiple-sklerose-news/ms-forschung/was-ist-dran-am-zusammenhang-von-vitamin-d-und-multipler-sklerose/
- Original study here, note also the comments of happy coimbraptients at the end of the study: http://www.cam.ac.uk/research/news/vitamin-d-could-repair-nerve-damage-in-multiple-sclerosis-study-suggests
- "So, any of the 1012 studies that you get on pubmed for the terms 'vitamin d' and 'multiple sclerosis' and that demonstrate the link between decreased activity of autoimmune activity is nothing more than a hype? Results of the SOLAR study presented at this year's ECTRIMS Congress? "
"... At most, they point out that therapy with interferon is safe and can be positively supported by the administration of vitamin D. If you want, you may like to have a prescription for vitamin D to the interferon 20,000 decristol really great experiences with it. "
- "According to Dr. Coimbra's research, interferons inhibit vitamin D metabolism, so the study was a kind of 'handbrake-driven ride'.
- a) was too low vitamin D dose
- b) the effect was inhibited by the concomitant administration of interferon.
- All the more amazing that the vitamin D-treated patients had an improvement in inflammatory activity and relapse rate compared to the placebo group. Imagine what would be possible with the sole immune modulation of TH17-Rektion by higher doses of vitamin D without interferon! "
- "The solar study has worked with far too low doses. Here, in the phrase about the Coimbra protocol that lies ahead of you, states that 1,000 IU per kilogram of body weight must be taken daily. With my weight - and you can see me in front of me - far more than the 10,000 IU used in the solar studies have to be taken. Vitamin D can do more if you follow the Coimbra protocol. "
- "I have been extensively informed about the facts, data and facts about basic therapy: Do you know, for example, the study by UKE Hamburg that only 14 out of 100 patients benefit from a basic therapy, but 28 out of 100 have serious side effects without any benefit? The brochure can be found here: https://www.uke.de/dateien/kliniken/neurologie/dokumente/broschüre-immuntherapie.pdf
- Dr. Coimbra, on the other hand, achieves full remission according to the NEDA standard in 95% of all treated patients with his protocol. "What that is, can be read here: http://tag-trier.de/?p=137
- "Your colleague and neurologist, Dr. Coimbra, believes that vitamin D levels of vitamin D are high in MS patients, so these high doses can not be as effective in MS patients as they are in healthy patients, and in more than 1,500 patients treated over 12 years, There has been no case of kidney failure, and as long as you are on a low calcium diet you will not develop hypercalcaemia. "
- "The opposite is the case: in nephrology (Nephrology), vitamin D is used in renal insufficiency."
- "Which study proves that?"
- "Dr. Coimbra did not get any kidney stones and nobody dies of it. On the contrary, 95% of his patients lead a normal life again. The 5% others did not stick to it. He has it. How he did it is in this expression. But well, you do not want to, is your right. "* Hand to say goodbye *" Or do you want to think again, to be able to do that too? "
- "This is not just a hypothesis, that is certain: polymorphic changes to either of the two vitamin D hydroxylases (especially 1-alpha hydroxylase) or the vitamin D receptor or to DBP (vitamin D binding protein) have been reported in identified and reported on various studies related to autoimmune diseases. "
- 17 reasons why are doctors reluctant to accept vitamin D 10 reasons
- 2000 IU of vitamin D- doctors trained that it was too much, but it is often too little
- Doctors rarely (15 prcnt) talked about Vitamin D and with very little ambiguity (96 prcnt)– Aug 2016
- Multiple Sclerosis: number needed to treat with vitamin D may be as low as 1.3 – Meta-analysis Oct 2013
- Is 50 ng of vitamin D too high, just right, or not enough
- Note: Coimbra protocol has a much higher target: 150 ng
- Vitamin D is the only dietary supplement which significantly benefits MS – JAMA April 2018
- Multiple Sclerosis treated when use high doses of vitamin D – meta-analysis May 2018
- Vitamin D has treated Multiple Sclerosis and autoimmune diseases for 16 years – Coimbra April 2018 includes great video in English
- Multiple Sclerosis – many reasons to believe Vitamin D can prevent and treat it – Feb 2018
- Multiple Sclerosis patients have 3X less Vitamin K2 in their blood – March 2018
- Perhaps K2 should be one of the protocol co-factors
- Multiple Sclerosis and Vitamin D – chapter and entire MS book - Nov 2017
- Multiple Sclerosis, Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s need more than 30 ng of Vitamin D – review Nov 2017
- Fewer Multiple Sclerosis lesions when supplemented with Vitamin D – meta-analysis May 2017
- Doctor got multiple sclerosis, rejected then embraced Coimbra protocol for herself and patients – Jan 2017
- Guide for patients on high doses of Vitamin D – Coimbra 2017